Pizza for Guys

🍕 Independent, hands-on pizza-gear reviews & recipes · no sponsored rankings

Adding Value To Your Foodie Moments

Pizza Oven Savings Calculator

What a homemade pizza really costs - ingredients plus the fuel to fire the oven - against a size-matched delivery or takeaway, and how long before the oven has paid for itself. Preheat times are the ones we measured, not the ones on the box. Every number is yours to change.

The short answer

At US average prices a 12-inch homemade Neapolitan Margherita costs about $3.73 - roughly $3.29 of ingredients plus $0.44 of propane, when you bake four pizzas off one preheat. The size-matched delivery equivalent of that pizza is about $14.69, so you save around $10.96 every time you cook. At 8 pizzas a month, a $499 Ooni Koda 16 plus $95 of peel, cover and gas pays for itself in about 6.8 months - realistically somewhere between 5.8 and 9.2 months once you allow for prices moving.

Two things move that number more than anything else: how many pizzas you bake per session (one preheat spread over four pizzas costs a quarter of what it costs spread over one), and whether you're comparing like with like on size. Change any input below and the answer changes with it.

Ooni Koda 16 · 8 pizzas a month

Yes - it pays for itself in 6.8 months

At 8 pizzas a month, 4 pizzas a session, you save $10.96 a pizza. After that it keeps handing you about $88 a month.

$3.73
to make it yourself
12" Neapolitan Margherita
$14.69
to order the same size
14" priced at $20.00
$10.96
saved per pizza
6.8 months
to pay off the oven
likely 5.8 months - 9.2 months

Over five years that is $4,668 you keep - after paying $594 for the oven and its kit, and $1,791 in ingredients and fuel.

Step 1

Your situation

Step 2

What you'd make, and what you'd have ordered instead

Size-matched. You're making a 12" pizza but pricing a 14" one. A 12" pie has 73% of the area, so the fair comparison is $14.69, not $20.00. Most calculators skip this and overstate the saving.

Step 3

What one 12" Neapolitan Margherita costs to make

Every row is a real grocery product and its shelf price - you pay for the portion you use. Edit the amount, the price you paid, or the pack size to match your own shopping.

Dough $1.29Sauce $0.35Cheese $1.25Toppings $0.39Fuel $0.44
  • San Marzano / canned tomatoes

    e.g. Canned peeled tomatoes, 28 oz

    $0.35
  • Extra-virgin olive oil

    e.g. Extra-virgin olive oil, 500 ml

    $0.08
  • 00 pizza flour (dough)

    e.g. Caputo 00 flour, 2.2 lb bag

    $1.12
  • Instant yeast (dough)

    e.g. Instant dry yeast, 1 lb

    $0.01
  • Fine sea salt (dough)

    e.g. Fine sea salt, 26 oz

    $0.01
  • Fresh mozzarella (fior di latte)

    e.g. Fresh mozzarella ball, 16 oz

    $1.25
  • Fresh basil

    e.g. Fresh basil, 0.66 oz clamshell

    $0.39
  • Extra-virgin olive oil (finish)

    e.g. Extra-virgin olive oil, 500 ml

    $0.08
Ingredients $3.29 + fuel $0.44
$3.73 per pizza
$0.03 per square inch

Step 4

The oven, and what it really costs to fire

The Ooni Koda 16 is the first generation and still sold - often discounted, which is exactly why its payback can beat the newer Ooni Koda 2 Pro. Just buy it knowing that.

Why one preheat, not one per pizza

We timed it

Real preheat is 30-45 min, not 20. 29,000 BTU burner ≈ 0.61 kg propane/hour - about $1.50-2.00 for a four-pizza night.

Marketing says 20 minutes of preheat. We measured 35. Using the marketed number would understate your fuel bill by about 75% of the preheat.

Firing this oven for 4 pizzas burns 0.64 kg of propane - $1.77 for the session, $0.44 a pizza.

Step 4b

How fast it actually feeds people

About 8.6 pizzas an hour once it is hot. From cold, 4 pizzas takes roughly 1 hr 3 min - 35 minutes of that is preheat you only pay once.

8.6
pizzas an hour, once hot
3
in your first hour, from cold
63
minutes to feed 4

The Ooni Koda 16 holds this pace for about 10 pizzas back-to-back before the stone needs a rest. These rates use the same measured preheat and oven-on times as the fuel maths above, so they cannot disagree with it.

The picture

When the oven stops costing you money

Ooni Koda 16Pays for itself in 6.8 monthsEverything you’ll have spent, month by monthOrder every timeBuy the oven & cook your own$0$441$882$1.3k$1.8k0612months of owning itbreaks even$722 aheadafter 15 monthsPizza for Guyspizzaforguys.com/pizza-oven-savings-calculator
Day one$594 out of pocket
Every month after$88 not spent on delivery
Realistic range5.8 months - 9.2 months

The range stresses every uncertain input at once - groceries ±15%, fuel ±30%, pizza prices ±10% - so the honest answer is a window, not a decimal.

Your inputs live in the link, so whoever opens it lands on your exact scenario.

Step 5

Which oven, for how you actually cook

Every oven below is costed with its own fuel, its own measured preheat and its own starter kit - which is why the cheapest oven is often not the one that pays off first.

Compare all 13 ovens on your numbers
OvenUpfrontFuel / pizzaPizzas / hrPays off inFit
BIG HORN 12" Multi-FuelWood / pellet · outdoor · up to 12"$280$0.37103.2 months✓ fits your setup
Ooni Karu 12Wood / pellet · outdoor · up to 12"$469$0.53105.4 months✓ fits your setup
Ooni Koda 12Gas / propane · outdoor · up to 12"$494$0.13105.5 months✓ fits your setup
Gozney RoccboxGas / propane · outdoor · up to 12"$564$0.488.66.5 months✓ fits your setup
Halo Versa 16Gas / propane · outdoor · up to 14"$594$0.22106.6 months✓ fits your setup
Ooni Koda 16Gas / propane · outdoor · up to 16"$594$0.448.66.8 months✓ fits your setup
Bertello GrandeGas / propane · outdoor · up to 16"$609$0.308.66.9 months✓ fits your setup
Ooni Volt 2Electric · indoor · up to 12"$724$0.04108 months✓ fits your setup
Ooni Karu 16Wood / pellet · outdoor · up to 16"$919$0.808.610.8 months✓ fits your setup
Breville Smart Oven PizzaioloElectric · indoor · up to 12"$1,024$0.068.611.3 months✓ fits your setup
Forno Venetzia Pronto 500Wood / pellet · outdoor · up to 14"$1,879$1.667.52 years✓ fits your setup
Gozney Dome (Gen 2)Gas / propane · outdoor · up to 16"$2,699$0.638.62.6 years✓ fits your setup
Chicago Brick Oven 750 HybridGas / propane · outdoor · up to 18"$2,750$0.73122.7 years✓ fits your setup

Links go to our hands-on reviews. We may earn a commission - it never changes a number on this page.

Use it anywhere

Take this with you

Put the calculator on your own site

Free to embed. The only condition is the credit link stays.

Keep a copy

A single self-contained HTML file - your numbers, no internet needed.

Cite it

Pizza for Guys. “Pizza Oven Savings Calculator.” pizzaforguys.com, 2026.

Methodology

Where every number comes from

  • Electricity - EIA Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.A, residential ¢/kWh by state, captured Aug 2026. Currently 18.44¢/kWh for US national average.
  • Ingredients - real single-unit US grocery products at Aug 2026 shelf prices, adjusted by a local grocery index. You pay for the portion the recipe uses, not the whole pack.
  • Fuel - 20 lb hardwood pellets $19; 20 lb propane refill $25. Burn rates are per-oven: published where the maker publishes them, ours where they don't.
  • Preheat and session times - from our own hands-on reviews. Where the marketed figure and the measured one differ, we use the measured one and say so.
  • Delivery / takeaway - typical US large one-topping, scaled by local cost of living, then size-matched to the pizza you're actually making.
  • Payback - (oven + starter kit) ÷ (monthly saving). The range stresses groceries ±15%, fuel ±30% and pizza prices ±10% simultaneously.

Market prices last refreshed 2026-08-06. Measured preheat times and burn rates come from our reviews and change only when we retest.

What this deliberately leaves out: your time, the cost of a failed first dough, and the fact that a 950°F pie is simply better than delivery. Those are real - they just aren't money.

Frequently asked questions

How does the calculator work out the cost of a homemade pizza?

It adds ingredients to fuel. Every ingredient shows a real grocery product and its shelf price, and you pay only for the portion the recipe uses (90 g of mozzarella from a 16 oz $5.20 block ≈ $0.29). Fuel is worked out per cooking session, not per pizza: the oven is preheated once and then bakes however many pizzas you make that night, so the preheat is shared across them. Every number is editable.

Why does cooking more pizzas in one session make each one cheaper?

Because preheating is the expensive part. An Ooni Koda 16 needs a real 30-45 minute preheat before the first pizza goes in, and that fuel is spent whether you bake one pizza or eight. Bake four instead of one and the preheat cost per pizza drops by roughly three quarters. It is the single biggest lever in the whole calculation, and it is the reason flat "cost per pizza" figures elsewhere are usually wrong.

Why is the comparison "size-matched"?

A US large delivery pizza is 14-16 inches; a typical homemade Neapolitan is 12. A 12-inch pizza has only about 60% of the area of a 16-inch one, so comparing them directly flatters the home cook. The calculator restates the delivery price as what your pizza would have cost at that pizzeria's prices, using the area ratio, and tells you when it has done so.

Where do the prices and preheat times come from - are they accurate?

Electricity rates are EIA residential ¢/kWh by state (Aug 2026). Ingredient prices are typical US single-unit grocery prices. Fuel is a real pellet-bag and propane-tank price plus each oven's own burn rate. Preheat times come from our own hands-on reviews - where a manufacturer claims 20 minutes and we measured 40, we use 40 and label it. Every figure is a starting point you can overwrite with your own receipt.

How is the break-even (payback) time calculated?

The oven price plus its starter kit - peel, cover, thermometer, first tank of gas - divided by your monthly saving, where the monthly saving is the size-matched order price minus your homemade cost, times how many pizzas you make a month. The result is shown as a range, because groceries, fuel and pizza prices all move.

How many pizzas an hour can a home pizza oven actually make?

Once it is hot, the rate is simply 60 divided by the oven-on minutes each pizza costs you: bake, stone recovery, and the gap while you stretch the next base. That puts most 12-inch ovens around 8 to 10 pizzas an hour and a big refractory hearth like the CBO 750 Hybrid nearer 12. From cold you get far fewer in the first hour, because the preheat eats into it: a Gozney Roccbox needs 40 to 45 minutes before the first pizza goes in, so hour one gets you two or three. Every oven also has a realistic back-to-back ceiling, after which the stone stops recovering and the bakes go slower and paler. The calculator shows all three numbers.

Which oven should I actually buy?

The calculator costs every oven we have reviewed using its own fuel, its own measured preheat and its own starter kit, then filters by whether you can cook indoors or outdoors, what fuel you want, how big your pizzas are and how many you cook back-to-back. It names three answers: the best fit, the fastest to pay for itself, and the cheapest to run. They are often three different ovens.

Can I embed this calculator or share my results?

Yes to both. Your inputs are stored in the page address, so copying the link sends someone to your exact scenario. There is a free embed code near the bottom of the page for putting the calculator on your own site - the only condition is that the credit link stays.

More free pizza tools

See all pizza tools →